Baseball, by the Rules

Intro

Play Ball!

Introduction

Play Ball!

A Called Strike is Challenged

The pitch comes in, the batter does not swing, and the umpire judges that the pitch is in the strike zone. The batter, however, disagrees, and feels stongly enough about that disagreement that they challenge that call.

The decision on whether or not to challenge a strike is entirely up to the batter, and they must make that decision “immediately” after the umpire makes their call. “Immediately,” here, is supposed to mean somewhere within a second or two. Also, the batter is not supposed to have “assistance” from anyone else, especially anyone in the dugout1. If either the time or assistance conditions are violated, the home plate umpire can turn a challenge aside.

To challenge, the batter taps the top of their helmet. This cues the home plate umpire, who turns around to signal to the replay booth that a challenge has been initiated (and accepted). The replay booth plays the review, and the umpire announces the result. The entire process is designed to take as little time as possible.

The ABS system's rules for what counts as a strike are the same as the home plate umpire's... mostly. What's the same? As long as the ball touches any part of the strike zone, the pitch counts as a strike. The difference, is that the ABS system only looks at a two-dimensional plane, rather than the three-dimensional strike zone that the rulebook spells out. So, yes, it's theoretically possibly for a pitch to clip the rulebook strike zone, but miss the plane that the ABS system is surveying. Such a pitch would likely be called a ball2. It's certainly possible that one day in the future, MLB will iterate its way into a three-dimensional ABS strike zone, but for now, the strike plane is all we have.

Ultimately, the ABS is either going to confirm the strike call, or overturn it. If the call is confirmed, the result of the pitch stands, and the batter's team loses a challenge. If the call is overturned, a strike in the count is turned into a ball, and the plate appearance continues. The batter's team retains the challenge, and can use it again as soon as someone feels the need to.

Copyright 2026, Tony Forbes

Disclaimer

Acknowledgements

© 2026, Tony Forbes

Disclaimer

Acknowledgements